Hi @abourne,
Unfortunately, this feature is not available with BuddyPress neither with Paid Memberships Pro and to our knowledge, there is no plugin that you could install to add this feature to your website. To go further, you will require custom development work.
We recommend you to require the services from Envato Studio freelancers (https://studio.envato.com/explore/websites-programming). This web platform gives you access to developers who have already experience with theme customizations, and for very competitive prices.
Best regards,